Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens have wasted no time turning the Iran war into raw material for their anti‑Israel worldview, rearranging facts to fit a narrative they were already committed to.

In the span of days, Carlson has accused the Jewish Chabad‑Lubavitch movement of quietly engineering a holy war, while Owens has declared she stands against Israel and tied her opposition to the death of Charlie Kirk, casting the conflict as a betrayal of “America First.”

What should be a sober debate about U.S. strategy and Middle East security has instead become, for both of them, an opportunity to revive conspiratorial claims about Jewish power and to recast a complex military operation as the outgrowth of a hidden agenda.

Their claims land in a movement already splitting along a newly exposed fault line. President Donald Trump’s decision to strike Iran has triggered an identity crisis inside MAGA, pitting traditional “America First” isolationists against the faction that still sees Trump as the movement’s unquestioned center of gravity.

Carlson and Owens have placed themselves at the front of the rebellion, insisting that the strikes prove Trump has been captured by outside forces and is no longer acting in the movement’s interest. What began as a policy disagreement has quickly hardened into a purity test, with influencers and activists treating the Iran operation as evidence of ideological betrayal. And increasingly, they are reaching for conspiratorial explanations that cast Israel and Jews as the hidden hand behind it.

Far too many Republicans are choosing to look away. It wasn’t so long ago that the GOP was sounding the alarm about antisemitism on the left, pointing to college campuses, polarizing figures like Ilhan Omar and the BDS movement while insisting that Democrats had a moral obligation to police their own ranks.

Well, it’s time for Republicans to look in the mirror. The antisemitism emerging from the right is no longer subtle, and no longer fringe. It is becoming more blatant and more dangerous than anything the party once claimed to see only on the other side.

To be clear, Americans can and should be free to criticize Israel, just as they would any foreign government. But anyone who watches Carlson’s recent content, for example, can see that what he is doing is not policy critique. It is narrative construction.

One of his latest videos, framed as an exposé on the “treatment of Christians in the Holy Land,” has already been dismantled by Israeli Christian leaders, civil‑rights attorneys and official data. Carlson takes isolated incidents, such as a fringe group of Jerusalem youths who sometimes spit near clergy, and inflates them into a sweeping indictment of Israel, ignoring the fact that Christian populations in Israel are growing, not shrinking, and that Israel remains the only country in the region where Christians enjoy full legal rights and religious freedom.

But Carlson packages these distortions as a suggestion that Jews are hostile to Christians, a framing clearly designed to inflame Christian resentment at home. Meanwhile, Owens follows the same script, hiding behind the claim that she is “just criticizing Israel” while amplifying conspiratorial narratives about Jewish power. That shield doesn’t work anymore. Their rhetoric is not about foreign policy at all. It is about priming their audiences to see Jews as the source of global harm.

What Owens and Carlson have become is profoundly dangerous, not only to Jewish communities who inevitably bear the brunt of this rhetoric but to the Republican Party itself.

Their conspiratorial narratives threaten to drag the GOP into the orbit of antisemitic ideology, especially among younger, highly online audiences who are impressionable and spend hours marinating in algorithm‑driven outrage.

This is how extremist movements take root. The resistance to this must be strong, unequivocal and immediate. If Republicans fail to confront this now, they risk allowing a toxic, antisemitic fringe to redefine the party’s future.

_____

©2026 The Baltimore Sun. Visit at baltimoresun.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.