Health

/

ArcaMax

Ex-etiquette: Privacy vs. transparency

Jann Blackstone, Tribune News Service on

Published in Lifestyles

Q. My 11-year-old daughter started her period and asked her mother not to tell me. So, she didn't. I found out almost two months later. Isn't this something my ex should have told me, even if our daughter asked her not to? What's good ex-etiquette?

A. This is a tender situation, and it sits right at the intersection of a child's growing need for privacy and a parent's responsibility to co-parent transparently. To be direct, yes, your ex should have told you. Not sharing this information establishes a quiet "you can trust me more" dynamic, and that is not good ex-etiquette.

Let's start with what matters most. Your daughter has reached a significant developmental milestone. Puberty isn't just a physical change; it's an emotional one. For many children, especially at age 11, asking for privacy isn't about secrecy or exclusion. It's about trying to regain a sense of control over a body that suddenly feels unpredictable and exposed. And yes, part of this is simply that you are Dad, and a guy, and she likely felt embarrassed having that conversation with you. That isn't personal. What made it personal was that Mom chose not to tell you.

To be fair, your ex was placed in a difficult position. She may have believed that honoring your daughter's request was the same as protecting her confidence. But this is where good ex-etiquette asks parents to distinguish between honoring a child's feelings and withholding important information from the other parent. Remember this, because it will come up again:

A child can ask for privacy.

A child cannot set the terms of adult co-parenting.

Menstruation is not a private diary entry. It is a health and developmental event that affects medical care, emotional support and day-to-day parenting. Withholding that information, even with good intentions, undermines the co-parenting alliance and unintentionally places the child in the middle. It also gives an 11-year-old control over the flow of parental information, which is not a role children should ever have to manage.

Here's the difference in approach now that you're divorced. If you were still together, your daughter would likely have confided in her mother, and Mom might have said to you in passing, "By the way, Lily started her period, but she's a little embarrassed to talk with you about it right now." Most dads would understand, respect the moment, and not make a fuss, because they are included.

After divorce, however, that same moment can shift. What once felt like sharing an intimate parenting responsibility can turn into a feeling of superiority. When parents are together, shared information protects a child's privacy. When parents are apart, withholding it can unintentionally turn that information into currency --"I know more about our child than you do" -- and the purpose of protecting the child is lost.

Here's the nuance. Your ex didn't need to share details, commentary or your daughter's emotional processing. A simple, neutral heads-up would have honored both roles:

 

"I wanted you to know that our daughter has started her period. She's adjusting and asked for privacy, so I'm keeping details minimal, but I felt it was important that you be aware."

As for how you handle this now, resist the urge to confront your daughter or express hurt to her. That would ask her to manage adult emotions, something good ex-etiquette cautions against. instead, focus on restoring safety and openness. You might say:

"I know your body is changing, and that can feel private. You don't have to tell me everything, but I want you to know I'm here to support you, and I'm not uncomfortable talking about these things if you ever want to."

Separately, address this with your ex, calmly attach it to co-parenting, not blame:

"I understand why you wanted to respect her wishes. Going forward, I need to be informed about major health and developmental changes so I can support her appropriately."

That's not an accusation.

It's a boundary.

Good ex-etiquette isn't about forcing children to share more than they're ready for. It's about adults sharing enough with each other so children don't have to manage the divide. When parents handle milestones collaboratively, children feel protected, not exposed. And that's exactly what this stage of development requires. That's good ex-etiquette.


©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

 

Related Channels

Amy Dickinson

Ask Amy

By Amy Dickinson
R. Eric Thomas

Asking Eric

By R. Eric Thomas
Billy Graham

Billy Graham

By Billy Graham
Chuck Norris

Chuck Norris

By Chuck Norris
Abigail Van Buren

Dear Abby

By Abigail Van Buren
Annie Lane

Dear Annie

By Annie Lane
Dr. Michael Roizen

Dr. Michael Roizen

By Dr. Michael Roizen
Rabbi Marc Gellman

God Squad

By Rabbi Marc Gellman
Keith Roach, M.D.

Keith Roach

By Keith Roach, M.D.
Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin

Miss Manners

By Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin
Cassie McClure

My So-Called Millienial Life

By Cassie McClure
Marilyn Murray Willison

Positive Aging

By Marilyn Murray Willison
Scott LaFee

Scott LaFee

By Scott LaFee
Harriette Cole

Sense & Sensitivity

By Harriette Cole
Susan Dietz

Single File

By Susan Dietz
Tom Margenau

Social Security and You

By Tom Margenau
Toni King

Toni Says

By Toni King

Comics

Daryl Cagle Jimmy Margulies Garfield Dennis the Menace Ed Gamble Rose is Rose